How to Verify Cruelty-Free Product Claims

The demand for cruelty-free products has skyrocketed, with consumers becoming more conscious of ethical and sustainable shopping. However, verifying whether a product is genuinely cruelty-free can be challenging.

Companies may use misleading claims, vague wording, or unclear labeling to appeal to ethical shoppers without adhering to strict cruelty-free standards. Understanding how to navigate these claims ensures you support brands that align with your values.

Tips to Verify Cruelty-Free Product Claims

Look for Recognized Cruelty-Free Certifications

The most reliable way to verify a product’s cruelty-free status is by checking for third-party certifications. Reputable organizations conduct thorough audits to ensure companies adhere to cruelty-free standards.

• Leaping Bunny (Cruelty-Free International) – Requires brands to adhere to strict animal testing bans at all levels, including ingredient suppliers.
• PETA’s Beauty Without Bunnies – It certifies brands that do not test on animals but lack independent audits.
• Choose Cruelty-Free (CCF) – Based in Australia, this certification has rigorous policies, including banning products sold in countries where animal testing is required by law.

A product displaying one of these logos has met specific criteria and undergone vetting, making it a safer choice for ethical consumers.

Research the Brand’s Animal Testing Policy

If a product lacks a certification, visit the brand’s website and look for its animal testing policy. Ethical companies provide clear statements about their cruelty-free stance, often including:

• A direct statement confirming they do not test on animals at any stage.
• Transparency about third-party manufacturers and suppliers.
• Clear language stating they do not sell in countries where animal testing is required.

If a company uses vague phrases like “We do not test on animals except where required by law,” this means they allow testing in regions with mandatory animal testing policies, such as mainland China.

Check the Parent Company’s Ethics

Many cruelty-free brands are owned by larger corporations that conduct animal testing. While the subsidiary brand itself may not test on animals, purchasing from a parent company that does raises ethical concerns for some consumers.

For example:

• Urban Decay (cruelty-free) is owned by L’Oréal, which tests on animals.
• NYX (cruelty-free) is also owned by L’Oréal.
• Too Faced (cruelty-free) is owned by Estée Lauder, which still allows animal testing in certain markets.

Some shoppers prefer to support independent cruelty-free brands instead of those owned by companies with conflicting ethics.

Investigate International Selling Policies

A major loophole in cruelty-free claims is that some brands sell in markets that require animal testing, like mainland China. China’s regulations have evolved in recent years, but certain products, especially special-use cosmetics like sunscreens and hair dyes, still require animal testing.

Brands that are truly cruelty-free will explicitly state that they do not sell in regions with mandatory animal testing. To confirm a brand’s selling policies:

• Visit their website or contact customer service.
• Check cruelty-free databases such as Cruelty-Free Kitty or Logical Harmony.

If a brand sells in China but claims to be cruelty-free, it’s crucial to dig deeper into whether they have bypassed animal testing laws through cross-border e-commerce or specific exemptions.

Examine Ingredient Transparency

Even if a finished product is not tested on animals, its ingredients might be. Some brands claim to be cruelty-free while using raw materials tested on animals by third-party suppliers.

To ensure complete cruelty-free integrity:

• Check if the brand verifies ingredient suppliers’ testing policies.
• Look for brands that require ingredient suppliers to provide cruelty-free documentation.
• Support companies that use alternative testing methods, such as in-vitro testing and computer simulations.

Use Cruelty-Free Shopping Apps and Resources

To simplify the process, several apps and websites maintain up-to-date lists of cruelty-free brands:

• Bunny Free (by PETA)
• Cruelty-Free Kitty
• Leaping Bunny App

These resources help consumers quickly verify cruelty-free claims while shopping, reducing the risk of falling for misleading marketing.

Ethical Shopping Made Easy

With the rise of ethical consumerism, brands are under pressure to be transparent about their cruelty-free status. By looking for third-party certifications, researching brand policies, and checking for hidden loopholes, you can make informed choices that align with your values.

Supporting genuinely cruelty-free brands sends a powerful message to the beauty and personal care industry—one that prioritizes ethics over misleading claims.

Cath

Cath initially pursued a Doctor of Medicine degree but eventually shifted her focus to writing. While she remains passionate about health and wellness, she also explores beauty and fashion as a creative outlet. Her diverse interests empower her to blend scientific insight with artistic expression.